Sayville NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Fantastic investment opportunity for a unique legal side-by-side duplex. Perfect opportunity for additional income and both units are currently rented. See broker note for rent roll. Current monthly rent is $6500/month. The left unit is a spacious 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath home. The right unit is a newly renovated 2 bedroom, 1.5 bath unit perfect for contemporary living. Each unit boasts central heating and AC, ensuring comfort throughout the seasons. The homes are complemented by fully finished basements, offering additional living space or storage options. There is a fireplace in the left unit. Both sides benefit from fully fenced, private yards, creating a serene and personal outdoor retreat. There are separate electric meters and oil tanks. Recent upgrades include new AC condensers, refrigerator, and oven. Situated in the heart of Sayville, this property is nestled within an award-winning school district, adding significant allure for family-oriented tenants. The convenience of walking distance to local restaurants, shops, and the train station positions this duplex as a highly desirable residence.

Welcome to 15 Roosevelt Ave!!! Located in the heart of Sayville, this 3 bedroom, 1.5 bath Victorian is a perfect blend of old world charm with new world amenities! Complete with a large spacious eat in kitchen with real hardwood cabinets, stainless steel appliances, stone countertops, gas cooking and hi-hat lighting - making a perfect space for entertaining!!! This home Includes a cozy wood burning stove and hardwood flooring throughout - embodying the true comfort, warmth and allure of a Sayville Victorian! In addition to its character, it includes a new 3 zone burner, inground sprinklers, vinyl siding, a full basement with interior access and recently pumped pre-cast cesspools! Do not wait, as the opportunity to own a move in ready Sayville Victorian as welcoming and charming as this - will not exist for long!

Incredible Opportunity Within Fire Island Pines! 25 Fire Island Blvd Is A Unique 2000-Square-Foot Property Poised Amidst The Allure of Fire Island Pines, Renowned For its Natural Splendor. Attention Builders and Designers! Boasting Generous Dimensions and a Flexible Layout, This Residence Invites Endless Possibilities For Expansion, Customization, and Modernization. Currently Set Up As 4 Bedroom/ 3 Full Baths; Whether You Envision a Sleek Contemporary Masterpiece or a Charming Beach Cottage, The Potential To Craft Your Dream Home Is Boundless. Don't Miss Your Chance To Make Your Mark On Fire Island Pines - Inquire Today and Unlock The Door To Endless Potential. Sold As Is, Cash Only.

Welcome to 52 Regina Drive in the quaint town of Sayville NY with all of its shoppes and restaurants to enjoy.. This ranch style family home features many upgrades for comfort and style including kitchen, windows, siding and insulation in 2013 making it very energy efficient. Hardwood floors, Central air and a wood burning fireplace creates a year round sanctuary.

Midcentury oceanfront with generously proportion deck with pool and hot tub. Intimate & inviting, 3 bedrooms, 2 baths. Sun drenched pen living / dining/ kitchen plan spilling out onto pool deck.

Diamond 3 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom Ranch, move right into this stunning home, with park like setting backyard, 16x40 in-ground pool, Fiberon Bi-level deck w/accent lighting, IGS, hardwood floors, field stone fireplace in living room, crown molding, surround sound and entertainment center, updated kitchen and bathroom, 1 car garage, full basement partially finished with Den, office and exercise room, egress window, Anderson windows. (See attachment for MORE details)

Welcome to 250 Johnson Avenue in the Heart of Sayville. This Beautiful Expanded Ranch Home Has It All. As You Enter into The Foyer You Have a Picture-Perfect Living Room, Large Bay Window & Gleaming Hardwood Floors Sprawling Through-Out. Upon Entering the Kitchen, You Have Custom Wood Cabinets, Silestone Counter Tops, Mosaic Tile Backsplash and Plenty of Space for Aspiring Chefs. Additionally, You Will Find a Formal Dining Room, Family Den & Sunroom w/ a Built-In Ac Unit, As well as Two Bedrooms w/ a Full Bath, Main Bedroom w/ En-suite, Full Finished Basement w/ Tile Floors/Vinyl, Living Room, Fourth Bedroom, Full Bath, Utility Closet, Washer/Dryer & Plenty of Storage. Conveniently there's a Spacious Custom Built Attached 2.5 Car Garage w/ Storage, 8 Car Private Driveway, In-Ground Pool w/ New Liner, 360 Video Surveillance Cameras/Alarm System Included, Nest Thermostats, 14-Zone Sprinkler System, .60 Acres of Plush Landscaping, Garden's, Large Corner Lot, Fenced-In Yard, CAC (Main Level), Roof & Siding (6 Yrs.), New Septic System, New Above Ground Oil Tank & Much More to List! This Turn Key Home is Ready for New Memories! Come See It Today!

Welcome to your serene oasis nestled in the heart of Sayville. This charming ranch-style home offers the perfect blend of comfort and style, boasting three bedrooms, three full bathrooms, and approximately 3000 square feet. As you step inside, you'll be greeted by beautiful hardwood floors that flow seamlessly throughout the home, creating an inviting atmosphere. Upon entering the kitchen, you have stainless steel appliances which are complemented by beautiful wood cabinetry. This home also offers a spacious finished basement which leads to expansive park-like backyard where you can enjoy the tranquility of nature. IGS. The attached 2 car garage offers ample storage and convenience. Don't miss your opportunity to make this dream home yours!

Wonderful Location! In the heart of Sayville, this spacious Brick-front Colonial sits on .57 acre on a quiet Cul-de-Sac! Built in 1985 with 4 large bedrooms, 2.5 baths, full basement and 2-car attached garage ... plus hardwood floors, fireplace, main floor laundry room, Andersen Windows and Newer Roof! Make this home your own!

Sprawling Corner Ranch Features Cozy Front Porch, Entry Foyer, Sunken Living Room, Dining Room, Large Family Room With Wood Burning Fireplace, Eat In Kitchen, Primary Bedroom With Powder Room, 2 Additional Generous Size Bedrooms, Full Bathroom With Large Soaking Tub. Large Open Full Basement, High Ceilings, New Staircase, Cedar Closet, Built In Workshop, Plenty Of Storage, Laundry & Utilities. Beautifully Landscaped Large Fenced In Backyard With Patio, 2 Car Attached Garage, Side By Side Parking For Up To 4 Cars, Central Air Conditioning 3 Years Old, Roof 5 Years Old, Water Heater 5 Years Old, 9 Zone In-Ground Sprinklers.

Incredible opportunity to invest your money in the heart of Sayville in the Legal non owner occupied 4 Family house just blocks from Main Street. Fully occupied with Rent Roll monthly $6450 which also includes 3 garages. Rents are below market value.

Discover an exceptional investment opportunity at 316 Fire Island Blvd, nestled in the heart of Fire Island Pines, NY. This meticulously renovated property, originally built in 1956, offers a blend of modern luxury and serene outdoor living across its 1400 sq ft of living space. Featuring three elegantly designed bedrooms and three fully updated bathrooms, each space within this home has been thoughtfully curated to maximize comfort and style. The heart of the home is its new kitchen, equipped with top-of-the-line appliances and finishes, seamlessly extending into an expansive new outdoor kitchen area, perfect for entertaining and al fresco dining. The crown jewel of this property is its exceptionally large and private outdoor area. Envisioned for the ultimate in privacy and relaxation, it serves as a personal oasis, ideal for those who cherish their outdoor moments. Financially, this property stands as a lucrative investment with a sale price of $1,500,000. It boasts an impressive rental revenue of $99,949 for 2024, achieving near 100% occupancy from June through mid-September. With rental rates peaking at $14,500 during holidays and $12,500 in the peak season, the investment potential is significant. The property's annual expenses are efficiently managed, ensuring a profitable return on investment. Financial Highlights: 2024 Rental Revenue:?$99,949 2024 Occupancy:?Nearly 100% (June to mid-September) Peak Season Rates:?$14,500 (holidays), $12,500 (peak season) Annual Expenses Electric Costs:?$4,000 Water Costs:?$600 Taxes:?$10,017 Property Insurance:?$2,300 Flood Insurance:?$2,500 Pool Maintenance:?$1,600 (May-September) Housekeeping:?$225/week (when occupied) This offering is not just a home; it's a lifestyle and investment opportunity rolled into one. With its recent high-end renovations, unmatched privacy, and proven rental income, 316 Fire Island Blvd presents a rare chance to own a piece of paradise in Fire Island Pines. Whether as a personal retreat or a strategic investment, this property promises to be a valuable addition to any portfolio.

Single family home, 4 bedrooms 3 full baths and one 1/2 bath. Full finished basement with 10 foot ceilings. In ground pool.

Spectacular, updated waterfront contemporary home in the heart of South Sayville on a cul-de-sac. Floor to ceiling windows, accented by water views in the spacious great room with fireplace and vaulted ceiling, all new eat-in kitchen with quartz counters and Thermodore appliances., custom kitchen cabinets and pantry. 1st. floor bedroom has a full bathroom. 2nd floor features primary suite with jacuzzi tub, walk-in closet and private deck and additional bedroom with ensuite bath. Office space with panoramic views on 3rd level. CAC, New roof. Bulkhead 105 ft. with a jet ski lift. Jacuzzi, New hot tub on a Trex deck. Effortless indoor/outdoor layout to make entertaining an absolute dream. Your home by the water awaits. Minutes away from the Fire Island Beaches

Completely restored 100 year old farmhouse restored to its original glory with every modern amenity you could wish for. This 6 bed 6 bath home offers new windows, roof , siding ,flooring, air seal foam insulation, HVAC ( 3 zones) , commercial kitchen, steam shower & central vac. Full service maids quarters w/ laundry & kitchen. The home also offers a large front porch, detached barn, master balcony overlooking professionally landscaped grounds of the yard. Through street driveway with possible future subdivision w/ proper permit, complete fencing w/ privacy hedges & irrigation. This really is home sweet home.

This Fire Island Pines Home is One Block From the Ocean W/ A Roof Top Deck W/ Hot Tub & Scenic Views of The Ocean & Bay. 6 Private Bedrooms W/ Private Baths & Balcony! Completely Remodeled, Italian Porcelain Wood Grain Floor Throughout, LED Lighting Throughout, Fujitsu HIVAC Units In Each Room, On Demand Hot Water, Salt Water Pool, Outside Shower, Trex Decking Throughout All Three Floors, Gourmet Kitchen With Thermidor Appliances, High End Spa Suite Primary Bedroom Gas Fireplace W/ Remote Control, Built in Surround Sound & Speakers W/ 4 Zones.

Welcome to this beautiful, move-in ready, three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath Colonial retreat in South Sayville just a stroll away from the beach and park. Beyond the inviting 2-story foyer lies a meticulously maintained residence featuring a splendid ambiance throughout. Custom window treatments, crown molding and laminate wood floors in both the Living Room and Dining Room. The Family Room has a vaulted ceiling and impressive floor-to-ceiling stone wall with gas fireplace which is dual sided to Dining Room, oversized windows and sliding glass door leading to patio. The eat-in kitchen has been updated and features cherry cabinets, Silestone countertops, GE stainless steel appliances, skylight over eating area, and second sliding glass door to outdoor patio for entertaining. The Laundry/Mud Area, with outside entry, adds practicality to the space. The Primary bedroom has vaulted ceiling with ceiling fan for comfort, laminate wood floor, gas fireplace, balcony, and custom walk-in closet. Embrace outdoor living on the wrap-around front porch or the Cambridge Armortec Paver patio in the private fenced backyard surrounded by lush landscaping. Convenient features include a custom-built shed, a spacious driveway, central air, a new hot water heater with a Weil McLain Boiler, three gas fireplaces, inground sprinklers, solar panels, and inside entry from the attached garage-Low taxes! This residence is a harmonious blend of contemporary style, comfort, style, and practicality.

via Sayville ferry to fire island pines

597 Cottage Walk is a welcoming retreat tucked into a private enclave of just 3 properties, The open living / dining room & kitchen spills out onto the large pool deck set amid a captivating garden. 3 thoughtfully appointed bedrooms & 3 full baths. Additional amenitie include air conditioning throughout, bluestone patio, outdoor shower and potential for private beach access.

Discover the tranquility of country living in this move in ready 4-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom Colonial. This delightful home offers a perfect mix of comfort, convenience, and natural splendor. The main floor boasts a spacious layout with a cozy living area, perfect for gatherings or quiet evenings spent by the fireplace. The kitchen exudes charm with granite counters and offers ample cabinet space for storage. One of the property's standout features is its expansive backyard, complete with waterfront access to picturesque Mill Pond. Imagine spending lazy afternoons on the back porch, enjoying the peaceful views of the water and lush greenery. The front porch provides another inviting space, ideal for relaxing and soaking in the beauty of the outdoors. Additional amenities include a brand-new roof, laundry facilities, and a sprinkler system. The driveway accommodates four cars with ease, while a full-size garage offers added convenience. A shed outside provides extra storage space. Situated just 1 mile from Main Street with award-winning schools and so much more. Don't miss out on the opportunity to make this charming home your own.

PRICE ADJUSTMENT. Secluded Water Island Estate. 2 + acres, 200 feet of ocean frontage. Paul Rudolph designed owners pavilion with master bedroom & bath. Open living, dining kitchen. Family room. Separate shingled guest cottage with 2 guest suites opening to large screened-in porch. Large pool & deck. Formal tiered garden. Private bayside boat launch.

The iconic mid-century Pyramid house of Fire Island Pines (built 1961) offers the most incredible views across the Fire Island National Seashore from Ocean to Bay, as well as unparalleled privacy. This unique property features top of the line structural construction (galvanzied steel beams) and flawless design and has been featured in the New York Times and other publications. Upstairs the main pyramid includes a great room with 25' ceilings containing a wall of glass overlooking the dunes and the open living/dining/kitchen and a double sided wood burning fireplace. Decks with dining and sitting areas face east (dining) over the dunes and west (sitting) over the pool deck. Downstairs is an oversized primary suite with an enormous bedroom, ensuite bathroom, dfressing room/walk in closet, office, and laundry room. Sliding doors open to the pool deck with a heated pool and hot tub. Across the pool deck are 3 smaller pyramids which comprise 2 bedrooms with a bathroom in between. For investors, this exceptional home also generates spectacular rental income (7% cap rate) over just 6 months of the year. A rare oppotunity to own a beautiful beach house that also produces extraordinary income.

Fully renovated 1963 Horace Gifford design on refined and peaceful Shore Walk. This mid-century gem is sequestered behind mature privet hedges and set back from the walk on an oversized lot for maximum privacy. Four bedrooms (2 en suite) and three bathrooms with central heat and air. Large sunny decks (front and rear) look out to beautiful mature landscaping with spacious outdoor dining, swimming pool, outdoor showers and hot tub. Professional grade kitchen. Move in condition. Very strong rental history.

Discover luxurious modern living in this sprawling contemporary home set on nearly half an acre, where sophistication meets comfort. Boasting four generously sized bedrooms and four full bathrooms, the residence welcomes you with soaring cathedral ceilings that enhance the sense of space and light throughout. Generous living space and a large eat in kitchen offer plenty of space for entertaining and the culinarily inclined. A sizable dining area also provides ample space for gatherings. The master bedroom, a sanctuary of relaxation, features an ensuite bath and an expansive walk-in closet. A unique highlight to this home is the bonus in-law or guest suite, complete with a separate kitchen and living area for added privacy. The residence extends its allure outdoors with a vast backyard hosting an above-ground pool, a charming paver patio, and an oversized two-car garage. The immense finished basement provides additional living space, ideal for recreation or entertainment, and TONS of storage space ensures practicality. Conveniently located near town amenities, schools, and public transportation, this property epitomizes contemporary elegance and convenience for the discerning homeowner. A list of improvements and amenities include: Roof replaced in 2020, 200 Amp electric service, Solar Panels and an 8 zone sprinkler system to keep your outdoor space lush. All information deemed accurate but not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

Essex Model in the Desirable Sunrise Village Gated Community. This Model is 1046 sq ft 2 Bedroom 1.5 Bathroom Original . 1 car attached garage, tucked away on side Nice Open Courtyard Location. Paver Patio