Sayville NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Harry Bates' ingenious take on a traditional chalet is one of the most distinctive properties in the Pines. The top floor open living / dining plan is perfect for casual beach style living. 3 Bedrooms, 2 baths. Amenities include a large pool deck with terrific cabana with wet bar & gym. Beautiful chefs kitchen, central air and heat and multi tiered decks affording views to the great South Bay.

This property is located on Fire Island Pines. A popular destination known for it's beautiful beaches and vacation homes. The main house has a full kitchen, Living Room/Bedroom with sliders, Full Bath and a Dining Area surrounded with windows. Sliders off kitchen lead to new deck with large heated pool. Cottage separate from the main house has 2 rooms, each have 1 Bedroom and full Bath.Updated throughtout with 200amps and plumbing redone. All Updated to making a comfortable and enjoyable place to stay on FireIsland with heated pool and new deck! It's a perfect spot for relaxation and recreation. The presence of a cottage with 2 additional rooms provide extra space for family or guests. Fire Island is a beautiful destination for those looking for a Beach Front getaway!

Nestled in the Heart of this wonderful paradise! This home offers a slice of heaven on earth. This stunning 4 bedroom, 2.5 Bath residence boasts an open floor plan, modern updates, ductless a/c units, a rooftop deck with breathtaking views and a heated pool. Siding on home is made from Hardie Board. Imagine entertaining with your updated kitchen with Stainless Steel appliances and wet bar, surrounded by large windows, sliding doors to outside decks or maybe just relaxing in the yard with your outdoor shower. This is a retreat from the everyday hustle. Your paradise is waiting!

Looking for CASHFLOW? This 10 BDR, 2 Bath Multi-Family Residence is operated as a rooming/boarding house. Each room has rented for $1K/month. That's a potential GROSS MONTHLY INCOME of $10K! This investment practically prints money! Updated Windows, Roof, Vinyl Siding, H20 Heater & 11 individual high efficiency heat pump/ AC units. Cesspool is updated and maintained. Brand new doors and freshly painted rooms with new flooring being installed. Each room has Its own Electric & Gas meter, thermostat, air conditioner, phone jack and cable. 2 Car Detached Garage Provides Additional Storage That Can Be Shared. A Rare Investment Opportunity That Will Practically Fund Your Retirement. A MUST SEE!

Classic Pines mid-century. Wonderfully intimate 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom set amid lush gardens just a short distance from the harbor. Beautifully appointed, the many amenities include a large pool with wraparound decking, glass brick detailing, Rais woodturning stove & beautiful furnishings.

Thoughtfully designed 3 bedroom 1980's Classic Fire Island Pines...open floor plan with hardwood floors and walls of glass...bask in the natural light and enjoy breathtaking views of the surrounding beauty. Whether hosting a summer soiree' or simply relaxing by the fire...Not just a home...an intelligent investment in our lifestyle...a sanctuary where you can escape the hustle, breathe in the sea air, and savor the timeless charm of this beachside classic. Must be seen!

Outstanding midcentury with superb ocean views. Situated high on the secondary dune. Three bedrooms 2.5 baths with large pool deck.

Classic Cherry Grove Cottage with a large kitchen, cathedral ceilings and great location! 3 bedrooms, including first floor bedroom and two more bedrooms on second floor! Rear deck with utility shed and outdoor shower.

Beautifully renovated midcentury. 4 large bedrooms. Sun filled open living, dining kitchen. Extra large, all day sun pool deck with hot tub. Extraordinary rent roll.

Welcome to 218 Bay Walk...A Jewel Box in The Pines...Fully winterized during the 2008 total Reno (Top 2 Bottom)...A true oasis of comfort and sophistication, this custom 2br 2 bth boasts, fpl, solar htd pool, glorious master suite with custom Versace-style grandeur, custom kitchen, hardwood floors, high ceilings and a flowing floor plan which opens to the exterior living, dining and huge sunny pool. This beach house seamlessly combines modern design with the tranquility of island living. The attention to detail is unparalleled. The open-concept design effortlessly connects the living space flow that is perfect for entertaining. The unground irrigation system assures your professionally designed carefree perennial gardens...are truly carefree.

Charming West End cottage just 3 houses off the beach in the lovely West End section of Cherry Grove. Hardwood floors, open kitchen/living room. Beautiful pool and deck surround with plenty of room for gardens! Central heat and air-conditioning. Outdoor shower, too!

Welcome to One Atlantic Walk. This exceptional waterfront estate is located in the secluded Water Island community on Fire Island. The property transverses across a continuous .97-acre from the Great South Bay to the Atlantic Ocean and comprises 3 separate structures including The Ocean House, The Pool House, and The Bay House. From the moment you arrive at your private 250' long dock in your 25' Steiger Craft boat , which is included with the sale you are in true tranquil paradise. Your own private boardwalk leads you from the bay straight to the ocean. Totalling 4 Bdrms, 5 Full Bathrooms, Fitness Room and a Lap Pool, Atlantic Walk is the definition of a Secluded Beach Estate.

A unique opportunity to purchase a "NEW" fully renovated 1940's cottage with a large, oasis-like private yard. Perched mid-block on one of the highest points in Cherry Grove, every inch of this charming 2 bedroom, 1 bath home was reimagined and rebuilt in 2018. Fully legal, renovations include: modern kitchen w/high-end appliances, gorgeous marble bathroom, fully insulated, NEST controlled central heat and air-conditioning, new doors and windows, new septic system, new plumbing with On-Demand hot water. New electric, plus new fencing, decking and roof. Outside, enjoy a new heated salt-water pool, outdoor kitchen w/sink, storage & grill, large outdoor shower and multiple seating and dining areas designed for alfresco living. Poolside Storage Cabana has Miele washer and dryer, custom storage and 2nd refrigerator. Select furniture available for purchase/negotiation. MLS# 3467150

Spectacular oceanfront compound featuring 4 units (2 bed/2ba primary; 4 bed/1ba rental; studio rental; 1 bed detached cottage rental). Plus basic plans for a proposed 3rd floor addition for 2 new bed 2ba unit. This double lot has its own private beach access and large deck overlooking the dunes, white sandy beach and Atlantic Ocean. 1/4 mile to Cherry Grove dock; 1 mile to Pines. Very private and quiet. There is great potential to renovate the kitchens and baths to increase seasonal rental rates. NOW AVAILABLE for SEASONAL RENTAL - Three Units from $20K, $22K & $30K per month for June, July & August. Weekly rentals will be considered. CALL MITCH NOW TO SCHEDULE A SHOWING!