Order by phone (800) 336-1027

  • Weichert Agent Features & Pricing
  • Web Design Gallery
  • Frequently Asked Questions
  • Customer Service
  • Fair Harbor NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale


    Showing Homes Nearby Fair Harbor, NY
    Beds:
    6
    Baths:
    6.50
    Sq.Ft.:
    4,600
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3539538
    Type:
    Single Family
    Subdivision:
    Fire Island Pines
    Lot size:
    0.16 Acres
    Year built:
    1995
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: D Katen Fire Island Prop LTD, 631-597-7000
    View additional info

    Experience the epitome of bayfront living in this exquisite residence overlooking the Great South Bay. Designed as a haven for sophisticated entertaining, every aspect of this home exudes luxury. Enjoy breathtaking panoramic bay views, indulgent amenities, and meticulously crafted spaces that redefine the essence of The Pines. Whether you're hosting grand soir?es or seeking intimate gatherings, every detail of this refined retreat ensures a harmonious blend of comfort and pleasure. The property boasts a prime location, commanding views, ample space, and an inviting ambiance. A state-of-the-art professional kitchen awaits culinary enthusiasts, while vast garage doors seamlessly connect the interior with a screened porch, allowing for a seamless indoor-outdoor lifestyle. Renowned architect Scott Bromley has lent his expertise to the creation of new mahogany decks, providing the perfect backdrop for your outdoor pursuits. Meanwhile, the gardens offer a canvas for your creativity, enhanced by the masterful lighting design of Randy Wilson. With a generous rent roll, this stunning bayfront home presents a rare opportunity to indulge in luxury living while enjoying lucrative returns. Discover the pinnacle of coastal elegance and make this unparalleled retreat your own.

    Beds:
    3
    Baths:
    2.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3554873
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.25 Acres
    Year built:
    1957
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: HomeSmart Premier Living Rlty, 631-352-2552
    View additional info

    Welcome home to 103 Sherry Street, located in the heart of the country village section of East Islip! This expanded split level home is on a corner property and has it all. As you enter the home, a large entry foyer greats you. This well maintained home features hard wood floors throughout the second level. The Eat in Kitchen features white appliances and wood cabinetry. A large sliding glass window opens up to the back yard. This home also boasts large living and dining spaces. Three great sized bedrooms are on the third level plus and office and den on the first level. Unfinished basement with storage. High hats galore! In the wall AC units. Large PVC fenced in yard. Detached garage with endless storage. 200 amp electrical. Oil tank in basement. National Grid Gas in street.

    Beds:
    4
    Baths:
    2.50
    Sq.Ft.:
    2,400
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3492708
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.28 Acres
    Year built:
    2018
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Eric G Ramsay Jr Assoc LLC, 631-665-1500
    View additional info

    Bayfront/canal, Babylon Beach Estates, newly constructed in 2015, Hardiboard exterior, all Anderson window and sliders, all radiant heating, gas heat, new kitchen, stainless appliances, Quarts countertops, wood floors, all new hi end bathrooms, 363 sf boathouse, 2 car attached garage, taxes $25,593, $280 per year cc, rights to club house and playground.

    Beds:
    3
    Baths:
    3.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3551183
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.14 Acres
    Year built:
    1998
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island, 917-710-1176
    View additional info

    Close to the harbor, 388 Neptune is a welcoming retreat surrounded by lush gardens and expansive pool decking, the ultimate in relaxation and entertainment. The open plan kitchen- dining-living room makes for casual beach living. Three spacious bedrooms, all with on-suite full baths.

    Beds:
    3
    Baths:
    2.50
    Sq.Ft.:
    1,500
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3509155
    Type:
    Single Family
    Subdivision:
    Fire Island Pines
    Lot size:
    0.17 Acres
    Year built:
    1955
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: D Katen Fire Island Prop LTD, 631-597-7000
    View additional info

    Thoughtfully designed 3 bedroom 1980's Classic Fire Island Pines...open floor plan with hardwood floors and walls of glass...bask in the natural light and enjoy breathtaking views of the surrounding beauty. Whether hosting a summer soiree' or simply relaxing by the fire...Not just a home...an intelligent investment in our lifestyle...a sanctuary where you can escape the hustle, breathe in the sea air, and savor the timeless charm of this beachside classic. Must be seen!

    Beds:
    5
    Baths:
    3.50
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    NEW LISTING
    MLS#:
    3558772
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.98 Acres
    Year built:
    1967
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate, 631-422-7510
    View additional info

    Welcome home to this Custom-Built Ponderosa Ranch nestled on one acre of property in the highly desirable Southward Estates section of Bay Shore. This meticulously maintained 3800 sq ft home guarantees abundant space and unparalleled flexibility. On the main level you will find an Entry Foyer, Living Room with a Large Bay Window, Formal Dining Room, Full Bathroom, Family Room with Wood Buring Fireplace and a Large Eat-in-Kitchen with Honey Colored Cabinets and Stainless Steel Appliances. The living areas on the main level transition effortlessly creating a harmonious and interconnected space perfect for both daily living and entertaining. On the upper levels there are 5 Bedrooms, including a Primary En-Suite, 2.5 Bathrooms, Laundry Room and a Secondary Family Room with a cathedral ceiling and a custom arched picture window which allows natural light to illuminate the room. This versatile space is perfect for casual gatherings, a media room, large office or as a kids' play area, The space creates an additional retreat within the home, complementing the primary living areas and enhancing overall comfort and functionality. This home has its very own backyard oasis and is an entertainer's delight.. The beautifully manicured backyard showcases a Blue Stone Patio with a fire pit and stepping stones leading to a 20 x 45 inground pool surrounded by Cambridge patio pavers. Additional Features include: Finished Basement, 3-Zone Heating and Air Conditioning, Central Air, 10-Zone In-Ground Sprinklers, Hardwood Floors, Tons of Storage, Gas Heat and Cooking, Loop Loc Pool Cover, New Pool Liner (2022), 2 Car Attached Garage, Two Sheds with Electric, Natural Gas Line to BBQ and Pool Shed, Generator Hook-Up, Radiant Heat Flooring in Primary Bathroom, and so much more!. Conveniently located in close proximity to all Major Parkways, Restaurants, Shopping, Schools, LIRR, Parks, Beaches, Fire Island Ferries and the Vibrant Downtown Bay Shore. This home has it all!!

    Beds:
    3
    Baths:
    3.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3547203
    Type:
    Single Family
    Subdivision:
    Fire Island Pines
    Lot size:
    0.2 Acres
    Year built:
    1950
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Signature Premier Properties, 516-799-7100
    View additional info

    This property is located on Fire Island Pines. A popular destination known for it's beautiful beaches and vacation homes. The main house has a full kitchen, Living Room/Bedroom with sliders, Full Bath and a Dining Area surrounded with windows. Sliders off kitchen lead to new deck with large heated pool. Cottage separate from the main house has 2 rooms, each have 1 Bedroom and full Bath.Updated throughtout with 200amps and plumbing redone. All Updated to making a comfortable and enjoyable place to stay on FireIsland with heated pool and new deck! It's a perfect spot for relaxation and recreation. The presence of a cottage with 2 additional rooms provide extra space for family or guests. Fire Island is a beautiful destination for those looking for a Beach Front getaway!

    Beds:
    4
    Baths:
    2.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    2,123
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3553104
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.04 Acres
    Year built:
    1965
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: The Agency Northshore NY, 631-870-0753
    View additional info

    Discover the epitome of waterfront living in this newly remodeled hi-ranch. This exquisite home showcases an open concept design with stunning hardwood floors throughout. With 4 spacious bedrooms and 2 elegantly tiled bathrooms, plus a beautiful gas fireplace, this residence exudes both comfort and luxury. The gourmet kitchen, equipped with brand-new stainless steel appliances and quartz countertops, offers a perfect space for culinary delights. Additional features include a versatile room ideal for a home office or guest suite, a cozy den for relaxation, and a chic bar perfect for entertaining. Step outside to a meticulously crafted stone patio leading to your private dock, complete with 50 feet of bulkhead, allowing you to fully enjoy waterfront living. Nestled in the coveted Babylon Beach Estate, this home provides exclusive access to a private bayfront beach, proximity to Good Samaritan Hospital, and easy access to Robert Moses Parkway. Moreover, you can effortlessly embark on a boat trip to Fire Island from your backyard. With flood insurance costing less than $130 monthly, this dream home offers a perfect blend of modern living and serene coastal lifestyle

    Beds:
    4
    Baths:
    2.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3557411
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.16 Acres
    Year built:
    1965
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: D Katen Fire Island Prop LTD, 631-597-7000
    View additional info

    Nestled among towering pine trees, this charming 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom home offers the perfect blend of tranquility and convenience. Located just minutes from town, this property provides easy access to all amenities while offering a serene retreat from the hustle and bustle.4 bedrooms with ample natural light and closet space, 2 bathrooms, open-concept living and dining area with large windows and hardwood floors, Outdoor Space ideal for entertaining or relaxation. Just a short walk to town and beaches. Enjoy the peace and beauty of nature right at your doorstep. Don't miss the opportunity to own this beautiful home in a prime location. Schedule a viewing today and experience the perfect balance of comfort, convenience, and natural beauty.

    Beds:
    6
    Baths:
    6.50
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3536709
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.16 Acres
    Year built:
    1970
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: D Katen Fire Island Prop LTD, 631-597-7000
    View additional info

    This Fire Island Pines Home is One Block From the Ocean W/ A Roof Top Deck W/ Hot Tub & Scenic Views of The Ocean & Bay. 6 Private Bedrooms W/ Private Baths & Balcony! Completely Remodeled, Italian Porcelain Wood Grain Floor Throughout, LED Lighting Throughout, Fujitsu HIVAC Units In Each Room, On Demand Hot Water, Salt Water Pool, Outside Shower, Trex Decking Throughout All Three Floors, Gourmet Kitchen With Thermidor Appliances, High End Spa Suite Primary Bedroom Gas Fireplace W/ Remote Control, Built in Surround Sound & Speakers W/ 4 Zones.

    Beds:
    2
    Baths:
    1.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3557009
    Type:
    Condo, Townhouse
    Subdivision:
    Forest Green
    Year built:
    1970
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Coldwell Banker American Homes, 631-673-6800
    View additional info

    Tranquil living at its best. This 1st floor, 2-bedroom, 1 bath unit features hardwood floors throughout, an updated full bathroom, living area is spacious and inviting, two generous bedrooms and plenty of storage. Unit faces the courtyard and perfectly located in rear of development near convenient parking and across from the many amenities this development has to offer...a salt water heated inground pool, perfect to enjoy your summer days, fitness center, laundry room, community entertainment space with kitchen for entertaining family & friends. Pet friendly, two pets allowed. Close To Transportation, Shopping, Restaurants, Schools and Parks. Sit back, relax and enjoy!

    Beds:
    2
    Baths:
    1.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    1,000
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3557685
    Type:
    Condo, Townhouse
    Subdivision:
    Forest Green
    Year built:
    1975
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Realty Connect USA L I Inc, 631-881-5160
    View additional info

    Why Rent when you Can Own? Take Advantage of mint 2BR/1 Bath 1st floor coop unit in Forest Green and Islip Schools. Updated Kitchen, featuring Granite & stainless. Seller is leaving darling Breakfast Nook Wood Floors throughout and rooms that are spacious enough for king size furniture. 2nd BR features a Murphy Bed allowing for additional space when needed. Call your agent now and see for yourself what a great opportunity awaits you. InGround Swimming Pool, Gym & Dog Run

    Beds:
    1
    Baths:
    1.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3533768
    Type:
    Condo, Townhouse
    Subdivision:
    Forest Green
    Year built:
    1970
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Netter Real Estate Inc, 631-661-5100
    View additional info

    Welcome to this spacious 1st floor Deluxe unit. This move-in ready coop offers a king size bedroom, large living room, dining room, and kitchen. Plenty of closet space, gas heat. Residents enjoy a Laundry Room, ample parking, a clubhouse. Enjoy a salt water in-ground pool, gym, and a dog run. Close proximity to Fire Island Ferries, shopping, parks, restaurants, LIRR for everyone's convenience in this pet friendly community. Maintenance includes taxes, heat, hot water and trash. Unit is in Building E

    Beds:
    2
    Baths:
    1.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3552516
    Type:
    Condo, Townhouse
    Subdivision:
    Forest Green
    Year built:
    1970
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate, 516-681-2600
    View additional info

    Welcome To This 2 Bedroom Unit Located On The Second Floor. Both Bedrooms Are Very Spacious, Full Bath with Bathtub, Kitchen with Dining Area, Large Living Room with Hardwood Floors Through Out. Forest Green Amenities Include Laundry Facilities, Saltwater Heated Inground Pool, Club House with a Full Gym and Kitchen. They Are Pet-Friendly and Even Have a Dog Run. Close To LIRR, Major Highways, Bay Shore Ferry, Shopping & Schools. Parking Included

    Beds:
    1
    Baths:
    1.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3555541
    Type:
    Condo, Townhouse
    Subdivision:
    Forest Green
    Year built:
    1970
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Signature Premier Properties, 631-567-0100
    View additional info

    Welcome to this spacious, sunlit 1 bedroom deluxe ground floor unit. Hardwood floors throughout. Kitchen features ample storage and GE appliances. Forest Green community offers clubhouse with pool, gym and dog run. Maintenance fees include - taxes, heat, water, sewer, snow removal, garbage removal. Close to LIRR, shopping, schools and Fire Island Ferry. Dogs and Cats permitted.

    Beds:
    1
    Baths:
    1.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    NEW LISTING
    MLS#:
    3556555
    Type:
    Condo, Townhouse
    Subdivision:
    Forest Green Community
    Year built:
    1970
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Exit Family Realty, 631-450-4777
    View additional info

    Move in to this well-maintained bright and airy 2nd floor spacious Co-op in he Forest Green Community. 1 Bed 1 Bath. Unit Boasts An Open Living Room/Dining Room Combination and Large Eat-In-Kitchen area. Newly installed carpet and freshly painted. Maintenance fee $902.04 includes gas, heat, water, sewer, garbage removal, snow removal, common area cost, exterior maintenance, ground care and pool care. Amenities include In-ground Pool, Clubhouse, Laundry, Gym and Dog Run. Located near LIRR, Shopping, Highways and Ferries. 12 Month Home Warranty available for purchase.

    Beds:
    3
    Baths:
    2.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3546791
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.15 Acres
    Year built:
    1970
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island, 917-710-1176
    View additional info

    Midcentury oceanfront with generously proportion deck with pool and hot tub. Intimate & inviting, 3 bedrooms, 2 baths. Sun drenched pen living / dining/ kitchen plan spilling out onto pool deck.

    Beds:
    2
    Baths:
    2.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    1,244
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3547172
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.09 Acres
    Year built:
    1940
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Island Advantage Realty LLC, 631-351-6000
    View additional info

    Move right in to this updated Colonial style home w/ 2 bedrooms, 2 Full baths. Refurbished wood floors, fresh paint, etc. Centrally located to all. Don't miss this opportunity!

    Beds:
    1
    Baths:
    1.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3547982
    Type:
    Condo, Townhouse
    Subdivision:
    Forest Green
    Year built:
    1970
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Exit Realty All Pro, 631-647-8844
    View additional info

    This 1 Bedroom Co-Op Boasts Gleaming Hardwood Floors, Stainless Steel Appliances, Raised Panel Doors, & Updated Bathroom. Maintenance Includes Care of Common Grounds, Snow Removal, Water, Trash, Heat, & Taxes. Enjoy the Lifestyle with Inground Saltwater Community Pool, clubhouse & gym. Unit is located in the perfect location within the complex.

    Beds:
    5
    Baths:
    2.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3468912
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.19 Acres
    Year built:
    1952
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Long Island Dream Homes Realty, 516-512-8911
    View additional info

    Back on Market! SHORT SALE APPROVED!! Fully renovated : 4 Bedroom/2 bath/2 living room/dining room/2 eat in kitchen, 1 attached garage. Gas Cooking Oil Heat. All information to be verified by ALL parties.

    Beds:
    2
    Baths:
    2.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3509725
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.15 Acres
    Year built:
    1989
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Vinnie Petrarca Fire Island, 917-710-1176
    View additional info

    Classic Pines mid-century. Wonderfully intimate 2 bedroom, 2 bathroom set amid lush gardens just a short distance from the harbor. Beautifully appointed, the many amenities include a large pool with wraparound decking, glass brick detailing, Rais woodturning stove & beautiful furnishings.

    Beds:
    5
    Baths:
    2.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    2,700
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3547745
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    1.14 Acres
    Year built:
    1969
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: One Realty Global Corp, 917-679-8288
    View additional info

    Located in the esteemed Idle Hour area of Oakdale, this expansive cape-style home offers privacy and unique amenities, positioned as the last house on a dead-end street next to state-owned wetlands. It features a spacious, heated 9-car garage with a lift and truss system, set on over an acre. The home includes five bedrooms-three upstairs, two downstairs, with potential for converting additional spaces into walk-in closets. This residence is equipped with a large solarium/sunroom, a new refrigerator and water heater (2023), and energy-efficient updates like leased solar panels and Pella and Anderson windows. Additional features include a wireless 9-zone sprinkler system, dual-zone heating and central air, 200 amp electrical service, and low energy costs at just $16 per month. Newly painted in 2024, this home combines functionality with a serene, coveted location.

    Beds:
    3
    Baths:
    4.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3556280
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.21 Acres
    Year built:
    1915
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: JLS Real Estate Group LLC, 917-410-0689
    View additional info

    Must see and move in ready! Beautiful home on a corner lot in a private beach community. Inviting downstairs space with modern kitchen, complete with SS appliances. Spacious den, with plenty of natural light and backyard views. Hardwood floors throughout. Upstairs features a spacious master bedroom with master bath, high ceilings and walk in closet. An additional full bath and 2 bedrooms fill out the upstairs living space. A 3-season room transitions to a backyard paradise, inclusive of IG pool, paver patio and outdoor countertop complete with built in grill. Detached garage, oversized driveway, and grass area round out what the exterior has to offer. Additional features include: central air, inground sprinklers, energy star appliances and on-demand hot water. Walking distance to the neighbohood marina.

    Beds:
    3
    Baths:
    3.50
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    Active
    MLS#:
    3557434
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.18 Acres
    Year built:
    1960
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: D Katen Fire Island Prop LTD, 631-597-7000
    View additional info

    This luxurious secluded home welcomes you with contemporary sleek designs. Large open living space with soaring ceilings and a gourmet kitchen wonderful for entertaining. Walls of glass greets your eye with stunning views of the pool area. This stunning home boasts 3 ensuite bedrooms and an additional powder room for guests. Enjoy an afternoon dip in your heated pool and then retreat to your fully air conditioned interior.

    Beds:
    3
    Baths:
    3.00
    Sq.Ft.:
    n/a
    Status:
    NEW LISTING
    MLS#:
    3558117
    Type:
    Single Family
    Lot size:
    0.24 Acres
    Year built:
    1953
    A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Coldwell Banker American Homes, 631-863-9800
    View additional info

    Magnificent renovated colonial sits on a perfect corner lot with very private mature landscaping. Brand new roof, black gutters and leaders, updated vinyl siding and many brand-new windows. Cultured stone accent wall and lower skirt, beautiful front portico leading to front porch. Brick raised flower beds, expanded blacktop driveway with cobblestone border and skirt leads you to an oversized one car detached garage with side storage space. Fully fenced yard with large paving stone patio. Back raised patio with 2nd portico with two white pillars, great for entertaining! Two brand new CAC exterior units, grand entry, open floor plan, vaulted ceilings, recessed lighting, and freshly painted. Brand new hardwood floors, many floor to ceiling custom windows with molding. Cultured stone fireplace, slider out to back patio. Brand new chef's kitchen with white cabinets, stainless steel appliances, black knobs, subway tile backsplash, granite countertops, lots of cabinet and counter space. First floor beautiful full bath with wainscot and decorative tile, large glass standup shower. Second floor brand new hallway bath with tub and shower, second floor bedroom with vaulted ceilings, enormous primary suite with vaulted ceilings, recessed lighting, walk in closet, brand new spa like bathroom with gigantic multi person shower with rainfall shower head, double vanity with dual mirrors. Private beach and clubhouse just a stone throw from the home

    The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of OneKey MLS, Inc. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. Per New York legal requirement, click here for the Standard Operating Procedures. Copyright {{date year}}, OneKey MLS, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

    How may I help you?

    Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent






    We respect your privacy