Forestburgh NY Real Estate & Homes for Sale

Discover serenity and luxury in this stunning contemporary lakefront home nestled on over 5 acres of private paradise. Boasting 4 bedrooms and 3 1/2 baths, this exquisite retreat features cathedral ceilings, a large, charming porch, a brand-new dock, and a reliable generator for peace of mind. Step inside to find elegant hardwood floors and an abundance of windows that offer breathtaking views of the tranquil lake. Experience the perfect blend of modern comfort and natural beauty in this idyllic lakeside haven.

This unique home has so much potential. Entry gate leads to the long winding driveway, and the open, level wooded 5 acres. Lake rights to McAuley Lake. Only 5 minutes to the reservoir access. Property also backs State Land. The 2 Story Contemporary Farmhouse style home has an open floor plan with craftmanship that can only be appreciated by seeing. Attached 3 car garage w/openers and with second floor access, 2 car detached garage with woodstove and solar panels. The home features include a beautiful foyer with double entry doors, engineered wood floors, fireplace with pellet stove insert with bench seating & storage, dining room, massive kitchen island with seating and storage, metal sink, stainless appliances, dishwasher, 6 burner propane stove with oven & griddle, large pantry with pocket door, mud room with radiant heated floors, storage and half bath with barn style door right off the garage. Enter your Master bedroom through lovely french doors, the ensuite has walk-in shower, his and her vanities, soaker tub, toilet closet and radiant heated floor. The walk-in closet has a washer and dryer for total laundry convenience. Plenty of oversized windows to let in all the natural light, on demand hot water system, split system for heat and air conditioning in every room. Whole house generator. Full unfinished walk out basement. Covered patio with hot tub and outdoor kitchen potential. Second story is unfinished and has the potential of several bedrooms, baths and large living area. Exterior is hand milled log siding from logs on the property.

Explore this stunning Colonial home nestled on 0.86 acres of land, perfect for year-round living or as a retreat from the city life. Located near Sackett Lake, residents can enjoy a public beach, swimming, fishing, boating, and day camps. Upon entry, guests are welcomed by a foyer with a coat closet. The main level features an open living room with a wood-burning fireplace that seamlessly transitions into the dining area. The eat-in kitchen boasts a center island, stainless steel appliances, recessed lighting, and access to an enclosed screen porch and deck with picturesque views. Additionally, there is a main-level bedroom and a full bathroom. Moving to the upper level, you'll find a family room with a wood-burning stove, an office, three additional bedrooms, and a full bathroom with a washer/dryer. The large master suite offers access to a private balcony and a master bathroom with double sinks, a jacuzzi, and a spacious closet. Heading downstairs, there is a legal accessory apartment with its own private entrance, a screened-in patio, a kitchen, a living room, a bedroom, and a laundry room with washer/dryer hookups. The attached two-car garage, driveway, and additional parking area can accommodate multiple vehicles. The backyard provides a serene setting to connect with nature and enjoy tranquility. Just minutes away from the neighboring town of Monticello, residents can access various amenities, major shopping centers, casinos, resorts and enjoy a convenient 90-minute commute to New York City. Virtual tour available.

Welcome to your serene lakefront retreat, nestled among mature pine trees and a sea of mountain laurel in the charming hamlet of Forestburgh. This tastefully updated ranch-style home offers the perfect blend of comfort and tranquility, boasting various entertainment areas, including two hot tubs, a fire pit, a dock, and a safari glamping tent. Whether it's early morning water activities, mid-day picnics, or late-night stargazing by the water, this property caters to nature lovers. Inside, discover three spacious bedrooms, two full baths, and a finished basement providing ample accommodation for guests. The main living space has high ceilings, a fireplace, and sliding doors leading to a deck. Adjacent to the living room, a screened-in porch ensures you can enjoy alfresco dining while soaking in the picturesque lake views. The kitchen is a chef's dream, outfitted with top-of-the-line Bertazzoni Kitchen Appliances, elevating your culinary adventures while adding style and functionality to the heart of the home. Close to local amenities and attractions and only 20 minutes from the Port Jervis train station for easy commuting into NYC. Visit nearby quaint upstate towns like Barryville and Eldred. Explore the Mongaup Valley Wildlife Management Area that abuts the lake association with over 12,000 acres of protected lands and lakes, including the Rio Reservoir just down Plank Road. Experience the beauty of nature and the comforts of home in this idyllic lakefront retreat.

Here's your opportunity to own a cozy mini-resort in upstate NY, minutes from Bethel Woods, Resorts World Catskills, restaurant row, Eldred Preserve, and all the sought after hamlets. There are 5 separate buildings featuring 22 Bedrooms in total! The main building being the largest has 11 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms, and a bar with a lounge area. Building 2 has 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. Building 3 has 2 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. Building 4 has 2 Bedrooms and 2 Bathrooms, and building 5 has 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms. There is also a large community pool ready to be filled and used! A lot of work was recently put into each of buildings. They were used as Airbnbs this year which were booked solid, including weekdays. Financials and projections available upon request.

Welcome to Forestburg's Historic Gilman Pond Depot, a truly unique property nestled off Cold Spring Rd on 3 adjoining lots. This historic gem offers a wealth of possibilities, particularly for investors, developers and those with a green thumb and a passion for agriculture. Situated on 3 lots, this property is well-suited for agricultural use, making it the perfect canvas for a small farm or vegetable business. Whether you aspire to cultivate a thriving garden or embark on an agricultural venture, this property offers the space and potential to bring your dreams to life. With its proximity to the Neversink Gorge and Lost Lake, this location is a nature lover's paradise, offering boundless opportunities for outdoor recreation and exploration. The tranquil surroundings provide an ideal backdrop for those seeking a peaceful and harmonious lifestyle. Forestburg's Historic Gilman Pond Depot is a rare find, steeped in history with fishery transport to the area. Immerse yourself in the pristine wilderness of the Neversink Gorge with a deeded right of way with full price. This is an opportunity not to be missed to explore the endless possibilities that this property has to offer.

Welcome to a truly extraordinary opportunity to own a piece of history and a slice of natural paradise with this remarkable historic Lakefront home. This 2,692 square foot gem, boasting 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths, is situated on a sprawling 7.18-acre estate with an adjoining 83 wooded acres, waiting for a visionary enthusiast to restore it to its former glory. Built in 1939 and designed by the renowned New Yorker, Eugene Schoen, as one of just five homes on the picturesque 48-acre Gillman Pond, a non-motorboat lake. Noted for its exceptional fishing, this property is a testament to timeless architectural elegance and historical significance. Nestled within the embrace of the Neversink Unique Area, you'll be surrounded by 5,466 acres of state-owned FOREVER WILD land, ensuring a lifetime of unspoiled natural beauty. Deeded right of way to the Neversink River offered only with full price. Located off Cold Spring Road, this property offers both seclusion and accessibility. You're just moments away from the Monticello Motor Club, World Catskills Resort Casino, Kartrite Waterpark, Bethel Woods, Sullivan County Airport, Forestburgh Playhouse, golf courses, shopping, and more. With its historic pedigree, idyllic lakefront setting, and proximity to an array of amenities, this offering represents a rare opportunity for those with a vision to create their dream home. Whether you seek a private retreat, a place for outdoor exploration, or simply a piece of history to cherish, this property holds boundless potential

Waterfront Cottage on Black Brook This charming two-bedroom, one-bathroom cottage is the perfect Catskill Mountains getaway. Located in Forestburgh, New York, just two hours from NYC and 20 minutes from MTA North Train Line. With its new metal roof, brand new appliances, and recent renovation this home is turn key and move in ready! This ample space allows you to comfortably work from home, host weekend getaways, or simply relax and enjoy the peace and quiet of your own private sanctuary. Enjoy all the outdoor activities and adventures the Catskill Mountains offer: -Fish in your own brook -Within 10 minutes of several public boat launches, hiking trails and forest preserves. -15 Miles from the Beautiful Upper Delaware Scenic & Recreational River -1 Mile from the Forestburgh Playhouse -16 Miles from Bethel Woods Center for the Arts (The original site of Woodstock) *Does not require flood insurance

Discover the perfect blend of tranquility and comfort on this natural 5-acre lakefront property on McAuleys Lake,17 acres perfect for kayaking and swimming. Nestled in absolute privacy, this idyllic retreat boasts a pristine swimming pool for cooling off on hot summer days and a cozy 2-bedroom, 2-bath cottage with an open concept design that seamlessly integrates the living, dining, and kitchen areas. Wake up to stunning pool and lake views every morning, and savor your morning coffee on the expansive deck while taking in the beauty of nature that surrounds you and then enjoy an outdoor shower! This unique oasis offers the best of both worlds a peaceful, secluded escape just moments away from all the amenities you could desire. Just 2 hrs from NYC and 20 min to Port Jervis train.

Beautiful private home move-in condition, Primary suite and two nice sizes bedrooms. Beautiful floors. Wonderful appliances including a new electric stove. There is a cozy living room with a fireplace. Includes a beautiful room that is heated and screened in for a den comes FULLY FURNISHED and great opportunity for airbnb investment!! Everything is new and updated including a new roof (1 year) - new deck - new furnace A fire pit where you can hear the water moving. Close to Forestburgh Playhouse. Bethel Woods, Resort WorldCasino. Water Park Shopping, Hiking, and more...

Great Bones! Needs TLC! Roll up your sleeves and bring your vision. A sweet place on 2.5 Acres nestled in the quaint Village of Fowlerville, Forestburgh, Sullivan County, NY. Enjoy this great private location near a beautiful waterfall in this reservoir-lake region. This home is a 3 BR 1 BTH with a scenic porch overlooking Black Brook.

An almost Century old Farmhouse sitting high on a hill with a beautiful porch and view of Fowlerville Valley, Forestburgh, Sullivan County, NY. Located close to the Forestburgh Playhouse and near Bethel Woods. Great Bones!! This 4 BR 2 BTH has wood features, Italian ceramic tile bathroom, and a unique over the porch Sun Room with a view. Experience the tranquility and excitement of one of the most beautiful reservoir areas in the United States.

A Paradise Farmhouse on a beautiful oasis of 7+ acres of unique, perfectly balanced field and forest on Black Brook with a stream, pond and large garden. This 4 BR 2 ? BTH has two screen rooms, a court yard and lots of deck. This gem of a home is just up the block from the Forestburgh Playhouse and near Bethel Woods, the Resorts Casino, Indoor water-park and Holiday Ski Mountain. Updated Old out buildings include: The Old Plan Road Toll House Barn, Chicken Coop, Pig Barn, Cut House and Out House. BONUS: Bring your in-laws or guests to the 3-season Mobil Home Coach with direct water, sewer and Italian ceramic tile walk-in shower with window view and additional outdoor shower! The main house has your own personal Spa with a Sauna, a double Jacuzzi and a single Jacuzzi. The property has a Christmas tree farm and a Spring Surprise of One full Acre of every variety of Incredible Daffodils! 7.11 acres of Sunny, Peace and Tranquility. This will be your own Shangri-la-di-da Valley!